Powered by Qdhui!

AFLW: Collingwood v Carltonyour photos

HERstory in the making: Lockout crowd at Game 1 of Women’s AFL @lola_clare: Let’s go ladies! 🏉👱🏻‍♀️ #aflw #womensfooty #herstory
SuZhou Night Recruitment

@sarahonga: Foot is back 🏉🏉 not a bad way to spend a Friday #AFLW

@usconsulatemelb: We found a @richmond_fc supporter at the #aflwbluespies

@danaebosler Heading into history #aflw #collingwood


@the3winesmen: The people have spoken. Woman’s AFL is here to stay, and it’s about time.

@em_sibs: Withnessing history tonight with old rivals #aflw #bluesvspies

@sammyadams85: Witnessin’ history #AFLW #daisypearce

@joseph苏州夜场招聘nnellan: So it begins #afl #wafl

@hlancman: First game in HERSTORY #afl #wafl

@aliston12: First women’s AFL Game!!! 🤗

@silkwoodau: What an awesome turn up! #wafl @afl @carlton_fc

@jayne.darcy: 30 mins till kick off and it’s packed in the stands at Princes Park!

@joseph苏州夜场招聘nnellan: Waiting for history. Womens AFL Ikon Park Stadium in Princess Park, Carlton

@celestepotter: I have never had the slightest desire to attend an AFL match, but here we are- excited to be on our way to witness an historic moment.

@the_sam_e: #wafl

@blueovaljoe C’mon da woods! #cfc #aflw #wafl #magpies #collingwood Go pies!

@veritycampbellcomms: Women’s AFL starts tonight. What an historic moment.

@hannahgraces: Its happening! WAFL first game, history made 3/2/17!

@rbchikan: Cheer squad!! 💙💙🏉 #wafl #gonat #32 #carlton

@elana_monteleone: It’s good to be home. Let’s go Blues! #wafl

@madbart66: Blues V Pies. Wouldn’t matter if it was tiddlywinks #bluesvpies

@elana_monteleone: Waiting for history to be made. #gamechangers

@marksmithbriggs: History beckons #aflw #gopies

@__rounders__: Super excited for #aflw #gopies #aflwbluespies

@latchky: Go blues #carltonfc #aflw

@seanjokane: Here for the inaugural game! Get up Blues! @aflwomens #AFLW

@jane_izzy_design:s Go blues! So excited to watch history in the making!

@francesob: Go blues #footytime #AFLW #carltonfc

@phoeboob: “You play like girls. Really well.” #AFLW #gothepies

@kimberleyandco: AFL WOMENS #afl #aflw


@dazzheadspace: At Princess Park with 3 generations of Pies Diehards @collingwood_fc

@sarsyj: #numberonefans #gohutchy #gopies

@madirobinson_: What an incredible moment in sports history to be apart of. Come on @collingwood_fc #AFLW

TweetFacebook[View the story “FairfaxRegional/aflwbluespies-what-a-night” on Storify]


Newcastle council begins detailed investigations and deep soil testing at homes above the old gasworks site in Waratah

UNDER THE MICROSCOPE: Crews drilled at properties in Waratah on Friday. Picture: Marina Neil
SuZhou Night Recruitment

A “detailed” investigationhas begun that will see around 200 samples taken from land believed to have been tainted with toxic chemicals from a former gasworks at Waratah.

An earlyround of testing saw shallow soil sampled from backyards but the second round will see deeper soil examined, along with vapour and groundwater.

The investigations are targeting an area bounded by High Street, Turton Road and Georgetown Road and a council spokesperson said they would provide “a better understanding of the nature and extent of gasworks-related substances, and what mitigation measures, if any, may be needed.”

“The samples will be tested for a wide range of substances associated with gasworks,” he said. “Additional shallow soil sampling will also be undertaken on public land within 500 metresof the gasworks’ footprint.”

People within the investigation area are being told not to eat vegetables or eggs from their properties, avoid having areas of uncovered soil, to minimise exposure to soil during gardening and to raise any sand pits or garden beds above the ground level.

A resident who did not wish to be named said she felt the jury was out until she received the results from the second round of testing.

Initial tests had already shown high levels of at least four toxic chemicals at her property, including lead.

“It’s good that they’ve got the ball rolling because this is all about our children’sfuture at the end of the day. I’ve got a son who was born here and some familieshave been on this street for generations.

“I’m just hoping and praying that it all works out.”


Robert Dillon: Sporting Declaration

DOWN AND OUT: Newcastle midfielder Ben Kantarovski receives treatment after injuring his knee against Sydney in December. Picture: Marina NeilHE has played more games for the Newcastle Jets than any other player, but injury-plagued Ben Kantarovski faces an uncertain future as he battles to regain a spot in the team.
SuZhou Night Recruitment

Kantarovski has not played since the round-nine loss to Sydney on December 4, which was his 135thappearance for Newcastle, overtaking former teammate Tarek Elrich’s club record.

He underwent arthroscopic surgery days later to repair torn cartilage in his problematic right knee, which has now required four operations, including a full reconstruction in 2010 when he ruptured his anterior cruciate ligament.

Kantarovski has since resumed training, although the club’s website says he will not be available for another week.

But at a frank press conference on Thursday, Jets coach Mark Jones indicatedthe 25-year-old midfielder was no longer a selection priority.

“I’ll be honest with you, I don’t know why Kanta keeps getting brought up,’’ Jones said.

“Kanta is just another one of the squad members.

“He’s played limited game time this year and he’s not a vital link in us playing well or not playing well …that’s the trouble, if you sit out for a long period of time through injuries, you start to drop down the pecking order.’’

Olyroos representative Steven Ugarkovic and experienced Mateo Poljak are seemingly established as Newcastle’s holding midfielders, having each featured in 16 of Newcastle’s 17 games this season.

With Ugarkovic out suspended for Saturday’s clash with Perth, rookie Johnny Koutroumbis gets a chance in his preferred position.

“Johnny Koutrombis has done a magnificent job and I think he’s earned the right to be the next cab off the rank,’’ Jonessaid.

“I’m very keen to see what Johnny does.’’

Koutroumbis and Ugarkovic have both signed two-seasoncontract extensions, while Kantarovski is one of several Newcastle players who are effectively free agents and open to offers.

The dilemma facing Kantarovski is how to state a case for reinstatement, given that he mighthave limited opportunity to gain match fitness in the 10 remaining regular-seasonfixtures before the play-offs.

Players returning from injury often get to stretch their legs in Newcastle’s youth team, but the youth league season is over. Adding to his quandary, each week on the sidelines is unlikely to enhance his bargaining position for a new deal.

A former Young Socceroos skipper who debuted in the A-League at 16, Kantarovski would appear to have reached something of a career crossroads.

His future may well hinge on how successfully the surgeons have been able to patch up his knee, a recurring issue that has sadlyprevented him from reaching the heights many were predicting during his formative years.

His latest setback leaves both the Jets and Kantarovski pondering a tough decision.

Can he become a long-term asset for his home-town club, and possibly a future captain?

Or is it time for a fresh start, in the hope that new surroundsallowhim to realise his potential?

Either way, Sporting Declaration hopes Ben Kantarovski’s best football is still ahead of him.

He’s had a wretched run. That, unfortunately, is part of the game, but nobody would appear more entitled to a change ofluck.

RISKY BUSINESSTHEY are great for fans and the broadcasters, but the annual Auckland Nines and All Stars exhibitions are a recipe for disaster.

Over the next two weekends, the NRL’s most highly paidsuperstars will go hammer and tong in two events that count for nothing on grand final day.

And if anyone gets injured, their clubs are handicapped before a ball has been kicked in the season proper. It’s madness.

Injuries, of course, can happen at any time.

But players, coaches and supporters can probably accept such setbacks as par for the course if two competition points are at stake.

FOOD FOR THOUGHTIT couldn’t happen, could it?

No matter how badly the Knights are travelling, no matter how many wooden spoons they collect or how long they remain without an owner, the NRL needs a team in Newcastle and would never abandon this rugby league stronghold.

Or would they?

News from America might make you think twice. After 56 years in San Diego, the Chargers’ NFL franchise is moving to Los Angeles, basically because the owner has found a bigger stadium. Food for thought as “Our Knights One Chance” organisers rally support for a community-ownership model.


Ron Medich murder trial hears of divorce, wire taps, and expensive contract killings

Ron Medich allegedly baulked at spending $300,000 on a contract killing. Photo: Nick Moir Ron Medich arriving at the Supreme Court. Photo: Daniel Munoz
SuZhou Night Recruitment

Lucky Gattellari is the key Crown witness against Ron Medich. Photo: Daniel Munoz

Lucky Gattellari, the Crown’s star witness, sat in the witness box with a fixed smile on his face, twirling his reading glasses around with some vigour.

He had just listened to a phone tap. It was October 8, 2010 and Ron Medich’s son Peter was heard apologising to Gattellari that his father wasn’t going to be able to meet up at the Babylon massage parlour in Haymarket as arranged.

Gattellari explained to a Supreme Court jury hearing Mr Medich’s murder trial that he and Mr Medich needed to talk in person as they were sure their phone calls were being recorded.

Two days later Peter Medich again phoned to say his father “got caught up – he’s not coming”.

Asked if he saw Mr Medich again, Gattellari replied bitterly: “No, I didn’t. My observation was that he was avoiding me at all costs.”

Gattellari was right to be worried about the fallout of the murder.

On the evening of September 3, 2009, Haissam Safetli, then 45, and 19-year-old Christopher Estephan had driven to the Cremorne home of businessman Michael McGurk where they shot him in the back of the head as he was getting out of his car.

A Supreme Court jury has heard allegations that Mr Medich was enraged over a string of law suits in which he and McGurk were embroiled. It’s alleged that in late 2008 and early 2009, Mr Medich asked his then close friend Gattellari to organise McGurk’s murder.

Gattellari said that after initially baulking at the cost, Mr Medich had agreed to pay the $300,000 Safetli had demanded.

“F—, that’s a lot of money,” he is alleged to have said of the cost.

Gattellari responded saying, “If you don’t want to pay it, let’s forget about it.”

But Mr Medich brushed aside cost issues. “No, it’s all right. I want it done.”

It was now a year after the murder and the police were closing in. A number of those involved in the murder had been hauled before the NSW Crime Commission, the jury heard.

On September 15, 2010 Gattellari organised a meeting inside his lighting factory at Chipping Norton. He told the jury that he thought the noise of the machinery would make it impossible for police to overhear what they were saying.

He was mistaken. As the conspirators talked about the police closing in on them, and their concern that “the kid” [Estephan] would crack, Gattellari was heard urging Safetli to “put his hand up” to save the rest of them.

“If the shit hits the fan, I would like you to put something in your handwriting clearing everybody,” Gattellari instructed.

In return, he promised that Safetli’s family would be looked after and his legal expenses paid for.

The jury heard the only problem with this scheme was that the only man with money, Mr Medich, was making himself scarce.

What none of them knew was that someone had “cracked”. It was Safetli, who was now wearing a listening device.

In another conversation recorded on October 5, 2010, Gattellari expressed the conspirators’ common worry about the police. “I believe every time you go to the toilet they know … they’ve got every f—ing move we make.”

Safetli asked, “How’s the big boss?”

Gattellari replied that he was getting divorced and that he’d been called in twice by the Crime Commission.

“Is he panicking?” asked Safelti, to which Gattellari replied, “No, he’s calm.”

Gattellari told the jury that the “big boss” was Ron Medich.

In another conversation Gattellari told Safetli that the rule of British law was in their favour. “You’re innocent until you’re proven guilty beyond a shadow of a f—ing doubt.”

“You’ve done nothin’ f—ing wrong,” he assured the contract killer.

“I have, Lucky, I am sorry but I have,” replied Safetli. “You’ve got to understand that in my position time is running out.”

Time was running out. Eight days later, on October 13, Gattellari, his driver Senad Kaminic, Safetli and “the kid” Estephan were arrested and charged over the 2009 murder of Mr Medich’s former business partner Michael McGurk.

Gattellari received a substantial discount on his sentence for his role in the murder in return for giving evidence against Mr Medich.

The jury heard that Gattellari had met Safetli and his brother Bassam several years earlier when they were doing some debt collecting work for him.

On one occasion Bassam Safetli said: “If you guys want anything heavy done or even a final job done, we’d been more than happy to help you.”

With Medich allegedly determined to rid himself of McGurk, Gattellari said he organised a meeting with the Safetli brothers, saying: “That comment you made about going further with a job, is that still on the table?”

He said the brothers looked at each other, went to the corner of the room to talk in private and, when they returned, they said they would take the contract.

The following day they said they wanted $300,000 plus expenses for the murder.

But the months dragged on and still the murder, which the conspirators referred to in code as “the tyres”, had not occurred.

Medich, Gattellari said, was continually irritated by the delay. Gattellari had allegedly already collected $250,000 in cash from Medich’s Point Piper home.

Of that amount, $45,000 was given to the Safetlis as an advance on the murder. Gattellari used the rest for his electrical business.

In July he gave the brothers around $6000 in order to go to the snow to kill McGurk while he was on a skiing holiday. But the Safetlis didn’t get organised in time.

Gattellari later suggested that McGurk be killed by a drug overdose as he was “a current user of drugs”.

The murder was eventually done by Haiss Safetli, who was accompanied on the night by Estephan, a 19-year-old friend of his nephew’s. Both pleaded guilty to their roles in the murder.

The trial before Justice Geoffrey Bellew continues.


People power pushes council mergers to the brink

“The byelection was the last chance we had to make our voices heard”: Marj Bollinger. Photo: James Brickwood An anti-merger protest outside Bathurst MP Paul Toole’s office last year. Photo: Supplied
SuZhou Night Recruitment

It was a policy dictated from the heart of commercial Sydney; from government office blocks in Macquarie Street and Martin Place, and from consultants’ suites in Barangaroo. But if the state’s council amalgamations plans are defeated in the coming days, or at least pared back, it will owe to political power exercised from RSL clubs, town halls, and showgrounds on the other side of the Great Dividing Range. Decision-making tends to flow from east to west in this state: here the west may have reversed the tide.

“We are laid-back people,” says farmer Marjorie Armstrong, 73, who has led the grassroots revolt against mergers in Oberon. “But you try and take local government from small communities and, yes, we will revolt.”

When Mike Baird stood for election in March 2015, he had not articulated a policy on council mergers. Yet in some ways states are always looking at changing the rules around local government. Councils receive no mention in ‘s constitution. They exist only as creatures of state law, created because states needed to ensure local facilities such as roads and street lights, but would not pay for them directly. In the bush, particularly, they remain important sources of decent jobs.

For the past century, however, the trend has been to shrink their number: since 1906 the number of councils in the state dropped from 327 to 152. This is why so many state politicians are so often asked to rule out undermining their independence, mostly in local newspapers who also depend on councils for both advertising and stories. “A Liberals and Nationals government will also ensure there are no forced council amalgamations,” the Nationals candidate for Bathurst, Paul Toole, told his local newspaper prior to the 2011 election.

Under Baird’s predecessor Barry O’Farrell, the government started looking at local government reform in 2012. An initial report, prepared by a panel headed by Professor Graham Sansom, recommended multiple functional changes, including allowing councils to charge higher rates for apartment owners. It also recommended fewer local governments. “NSW simply cannot sustain 152 councils,” the panel’s final report in late 2013 said. “There are shortages of highly-skilled personnel. The shortage of engineers, for example, is a significant factor limiting the capacity of councils to deal with infrastructure backlogs.”

By the 2015 election, Baird had not signalled what he would do on the issue. But he also refused to rule out forced mergers. Soon after the election, councils were asked to submit proposals as to why they should continue to stand alone, or to consider aligning themselves with neighbours for voluntary mergers. The result was a frenzy of deal-making and, in places, the nascent signs of a resistance. In the eastern suburbs, for instance, Waverley and Randwick councils agreed to a merger, while Woollahra resolved to stand alone. In the inner west, Labor and Liberal councillors agreed to a merger between Ashfield, Leichhardt, and Marrickville, though the area’s Greens and independents said the councils should stand and fight.

Country men and women also started organising. “There were people from Oberon writing to politicians,” says Armstrong “Country people don’t do that. I was stunned we could even get people to rally.”

In October 2015, over 600 people packed the local RSL in Oberon for a community vote on the issue.

Oberon Shire, home to around 5000 people largely employed in farming and forestry, was facing the prospect of being merged with the much larger Bathurst Council. The RSL vote was emphatic: 94.3 per cent were against the merger. A few months later, it was standing room only as locals crowded into a second meeting at the Oberon showgrounds. The public meeting was open to comment, and 83 people registered to speak – all but one of them in opposition to the merger.

In Cabonne Shire, less than two hours’ drive away, a similar movement was afoot. In May 2015, community group Amalgamation No Thank You (ANTY) formed after 400 locals turned up to a meeting in Molong to protest the proposed merger with Orange and Blayney councils. In New England, which was expected to host a tough battle in the July 2016 election, federal Nationals leader and canny retail politician Barnaby Joyce started to campaign against any forced merger of the small Walcha council.

The result was that the eventual announcement of forced mergers in May 2016 was both a bombshell, yet only a partial job. Baird and Toole, the local government minister, announced the creation of 19 new bodies formed from the immediate sacking of 42 councils. But they didn’t touch Walcha because of Joyce’s intervention. And they didn’t create a further nine councils, to be formed from the sacking of 25 existing bodies, because some of those councils had signalled their intent to challenge their mergers through the courts.

But the announcement did not quell the opposition. In fact, the manner in which it was made only intensified the disquiet. Mayors and councillors were given little or no forewarning of their dismissal. Bob Stewart, Mayor of Bombala in the state’s Monaro region, was driving into town from his farm when he learned by ABC radio he and his colleagues had been sacked.

“We could never get a meeting,” says Marj Bollinger, a Molong-local and ANTY spokeswoman of her attempts to talk to the government. “They were invited to every rally, every meeting, everything we had. They were never available.”

Toole, who had once promised Oberon locals he would oppose mergers and was now in charge of implementing them, was not explaining himself to the community, Oberon mayor Kathy Sajowitz says.

“There is a general feeling in the community Mr Toole has let Oberon down,” she says. “The community has lost faith in their local member.”

Adding to the government’s troubles, it found it increasingly hard to sell the potential benefits of mergers in local media that had always had a close relationships with its councils and councillors. On the radio, Alan Jones was decrying Baird’s despotism. Those who had been agnostic or supportive of mergers found that the issue had been swept up in fast-surging anti-government sentiment. The narrative had been established: mergers were on the nose.

The opportunity to fight back emerged in November when a by-election was held in Orange to replace Andrew Gee, a National who had left for federal parliament. By this stage, regional community groups had become something of a network of anti-amalgamation activists. They crossed shire districts for rallies and protests, placarded Cabonne, and on election day, manned polling booths in Orange.

“The byelection was the last chance we had to make our voices heard,” says Bollinger.

The result, also influenced by Baird’s greyhound racing ban, was a crushing loss for the Nationals in a seat it had held by almost 22 per cent. The Shooters, Fishers and Farmers Party won its first ever lower-house position. An emboldened Robert Borsak, one of its two upper house MLCs, told Fairfax Media at the time preparations were under way for a lower house campaign for the 2019 election. The party, which has been consistent in its opposition to forced mergers, intends to take on the Nationals in eight to 10 seats.

For the Nationals, the loss precipitated a spill. The Member for Monaro, John Barilaro, claimed the leadership and the deputy premiership from Troy Grant, and started on trying to repair the party’s relationship with its bush base. In December, he met with the Oberon anti-amalgamation group that had previously failed to gain a meeting with Toole. Spokeswoman Marj Armstrong articulated to Barilaro a sentiment bubbling across the state’s pending council districts. “We won’t give in, and we won’t give up. And we will put the Liberals and Nationals last every time we vote,” says Armstrong of her message.

In the heights of government, the change in political sentiment has been rapid. When Baird stood down last month, Barilaro immediately insisted there would be no more forced amalgamations in country areas. And the day before the incoming premier, Gladys Berejiklian, was unanimously elected Liberal party leader, some of her closest confidantes and advisers met to discuss controversial policy areas that were ripe for dumping or overhaul. Council amalgamations was first on the list. Keith Rhoades, the president of industry group Local Government NSW, said he had hour-long meetings with both Barilaro and new Local Government Minister Gabrielle Upton on Wednesday. “I found them to be very receptive,” says Rhoades.

Even now, a third of the proposed new councils are still pending the resolution of legal disputes. While that drags on, 29 councils are in limbo. Many councillors and mayors who were elected on four-year terms and were due to face an election in September last year are now serving overtime. Late last year, the NSW electoral commission added another layer of complexity to the unfolding democratic debacle when it said it may not be able to hold elections until 2020 for councils whose disputes extend beyond August. Such a delay would expose the government to wrath of voters at the 2019 state election.

Yet the unravelling of the amalgamations policy may be as messy as the policy’s development. There is as yet no clear indication of what the government will do, though Fairfax Media has reported there is likely to be a halt for further forced amalgamations and mini-plebiscites to allow for communities to decide the future of their councils. It remains unclear what will happen to councils that have already been merged – though one suggestion is that they too could face plebiscites about the prospects of de-merging, potentially as late as 2020. Berejiklian said this week a decision was “imminent” and councils that have fought the proposal are sniffing victory.

“This is a win for democracy,” says Woollahra Mayor Toni Zeltzer. “Clearly the state government has listened and they have got the message loud and clear that local communities want to have a say on the future of their local areas.”

However Upton need look no further than her Vaucluse electorate for an indication of the complexities to come. Although Woollahra is firmly opposed to a merger (a position endorsed by Upton as recently as 2015), Waverley and Randwick remain keen. “To a certain extent Waverley has already had a plebiscite,” Waverley’s Mayor Sally Betts says. Surveys of residents and ratepayers showed strong support for the amalgamation in that area. “We’ve identified fantastic savings for all our residents, including Woollahra residents. It would be a pity. Our residents would lose out on some pretty good savings and funding to fix up all sorts of infrastructure.”

But the benefits were evaluated based on the three-council scenario, and should the government put a new proposition on the table – such as a merger just with Randwick Council – all bets are off. “We would need to go back and do a completely different assessment,” Cr Betts says, adding “If the government changes its policy we would prefer to stand by ourselves.”

And if Woollahra Council, which has already spent $850,000 on legal appeals, is allowed to remain independent while other mergers stand, that is sure to stoke questions of political equity. It would mean, for instance, there would be one council for Woollahra’s 60,000 residents (in the city’s most exclusive suburbs), and one council for Canterbury-Bankstown’s 360,000 residents. Hunters Hill, with its 15,000 residents, continues to fight to stand alone.

“It just stinks, it’s got politics written all over it,” says the former mayor of Parramatta, Paul Garrard, who says he will be campaigning for Cumberland Council to be de-merged.

“It’s like there’s two laws in this place. The inner city and west are being treated differently and now there’s a fear we are going to be treated from our country cousins as well,” says Garrard.

Unscrambling mergers that have proceeded would be its own nightmare. The government has already paid out hundreds of millions of dollars in incentive payments to merged councils, on top of the millions it spent on consultants such as KPMG to prepare reports into the mergers.

One issue is that if there were plebiscites would those plebiscites provide the opportunity for residents in the old council areas to vote? Or would the votes of the new combined council areas be tallied together? The results could point to very different outcomes.

There are myriad of other practical considerations. Administrator of the new Inner West Council, Richard Pearson, says reverting to three councils – Marrickville, Leichhardt and Ashfield – would involve unpicking the “very well advanced” integration process, and imbue the council’s functions with uncertainty.

“The prospect of a plebiscite means you would have to also be more conservative in your decision-making,” says Pearson, scheduled to be replaced by elected councillors in September. “You don’t want to be spending public money and then in six months time have to reverse your decisions.”

Long-term savings which underpinned the rationale of the merger process, and made largely from the retrenchment of staff, would immediately be jettisoned. Redundancy packages paid out to former general managers, and other senior management across the three councils would be sunk costs.

“You’d have to re-recruit a whole management layer,” he says. “You are reinstituting a cost that the merger was designed to save.”

Restoring the three councils management structures is expected to cost $4.5 million annually. While the councils await a clear decision from the Berejiklian government, the uncertainty is destabilising for council staff. “There’s a lot of people here who are saying ‘What’s going on?’,” Pearson said.

Greg Wright, the administrator of Bayside Council formed in September from the former Botany and Rockdale councils, said it would be increasingly difficult to pick apart functions that had started to come together. “We are starting to integrate systems and people and locations,” Wright said.

Another factor is that while a backdown on mergers might deliver some political reward, Berejiklian may also face a backlash within her own party.

Fairfax Media has been told many Liberal councillors who agreed to back mergers in their own areas to support the government are furious at the prospect of a plebiscite option. “After doing the right thing by the party and local government state wide, to let these recalcitrant councils off the hook is a betrayal of good councillors across the state,” said a senior Liberal local government source.

And then there is the business community, and the original arguments in favour of amalgamations. “Whatever they do will have consequences,” says Patricia Forsythe from the Sydney Business Chamber.

“The future of Sydney requires strong local government, it requires them to have adequate resources and infrastructure to manage the growth and none of that has changed,” says Forsythe, who would prefer Sydney’s councils reduced to only six.

More by-elections may nevertheless drive the changes. After the retirement of Baird and health minister Jillian Skinner, Berejiklian faces polls in the seats of Manly and North Shore – both areas where the mergers issue has been a flashpoint of community anger. Both seats have been historically vulnerable to strong independent candidates.

On the North Shore, Mosman mayor Peter Abelson says the anti-merge voice will be heard “loud and clear” at the ballot box. “There’s no doubt that if there were a by-election without this being sorted out there would be a very strong protest vote against the Liberals.”

According to sources, the Premier wants a resolution on the issue before Parliament returns on Tuesday, February 14.

Fixing the merger mess may be a daunting and costly task with its own political risks. But the prospect of a repeat of the Orange result in these two Liberal heartland seats could just be enough to convince Berejiklian it is worth it.


Suburban office market stirred by sales

Two interconnected buildings at 1100 Pascoe Vale Road next to the Broadmeadows Railway Station sold for an undisclosed price believed to be around $10 million. Photo: SuppliedPerth-based syndicator Property Bank is preparing to recycle two Melbourne office assets after successfully offloading a suburban building last year for $23.5 million at a peak point in the property cycle.
SuZhou Night Recruitment

Property Bank’s move follows the year’s first sale of another small office in Broadmeadows.

The syndicator has called for submissions from estate agents on a three-level office in the Richmond Corporate Park which it purchased seven years ago for $18.5 million.

A second suburban office asset in Market Street South Melbourne that the syndicator purchased in 2011 for $8.95 million is also likely to be offered to the market, said people familiar with the matter who didn’t want to be named.

Both assets have been held by the fund for more than six years and would see significant upside if sold in the present market.

Value estimates vary but both offices have been refurbished and are fully let.

The Richmond building at 8/658 Church Street could fetch in excess of $40 million, while the three-level South Melbourne office at 17-33 Market Street might go for more than $15 million.

Property Bank would need to get sign off from fund investors before putting the assets up for sale. The group was approached for comment.

The office that the fund manager sold at 630 Church Street in August last year transacted on a 5.1 per cent yield, highlighting the strength of one of Melbourne’s most sought-after inner-city pockets.

It was snapped up by Manny Stul and stepson Paul Solomon, the pair behind global toy powerhouse Moose Enterprises whose Shopkins Small Mart figurines are on the must-have list of millions of girls aged four to 11 around the world.

Meanwhile, an office owned and developed by Victorian Rail Track in Melbourne’s outer north was purchased by a private investor.

Agents Gray Johnson, Cushman & Wakefield and Kypa Real Estate transacted the two interconnected buildings at 1100 Pascoe Vale Road next to the Broadmeadows Railway Station for an undisclosed price believed to be around $10 million.

The building has a mix of 18 public and private sector tenants returning annual rental income around $1.2 million.

Tenants include Victorian Legal Aid, MIA, Wesley Mission Victoria and Campbell Page . oOh! Media and Vodafone have signage and telecommunications facilities on the building.

Gray Johnson director Matt Hoath said the building had an estimated net lettable area of 4238 square metres and rental potential of $1.35 million if fully occupied and leased.


One-third of NSW children prefer fine dining over fast food: OpenTable survey

Julia Lipari and her daughters, Isabella (left) and Lily (right) dig in at Otto in Woolloomooloo. Photo: Dominic LorrimerWhen it comes to children and food, fussy eating now has a whole new meaning.
SuZhou Night Recruitment

Kids are going gourmet, swapping fish fingers for lobster, sausages for wagyu beef and cordial for coconut milk.

One-third of NSW children prefer fine dining over fast food and 49 per cent have dined at a hatted restaurant at least once, a new survey for OpenTable has found.

Three-quarters of n parents say their children eat out more often than they did growing up, with 18 per cent taking their kids to a restaurant at least once a week. A quarter of parents are willing to spend over $26 on a meal for their child.

North shore mother Julia Lipari has always encouraged her four daughters to try different foods and said eating together was an important part of family life.

She said her middle children Lily, 8, and Isabella, 7, were “absolute foodies” with adventurous tastes, happily eating everything from curries and sushi to olives, anchovies and blue vein cheese. “They’ll basically try anything,” Mrs Lipari said.

Like 75 per cent of n parents surveyed, she said her kids preferred to order from the adult menu rather than the children’s menu when dining out.

“I often try to talk them into ordering off the kids’ menu because it’s cheaper, but then they get jealous of what we’re having,” she said. “If we go out to breakfast they’ll want the smashed avocado and haloumi. If I’m entertaining and I put out a platter … they come and eat half of it.”

Lily said she liked trying new foods. “If you don’t like it, you don’t have to eat it. But if you do, then it’s good.”

Mrs Lipari said that as a schoolboy in  her Italian husband was too embarrassed to take spaghetti to school for lunch. But in today’s multicultural society kids were open to all kinds of flavours and cuisines.

“Even at the school canteen they have hokkien noodles and sushi, so they are exposed to a really wide range of things,” she said.

The survey of 1250 people nationwide was conducted for OpenTable, the world’s leading provider of online restaurant reservations. “As a nation home to such a vibrant food scene, it’s exciting to see children are so engaged with emerging food trends and open to taste testing multicultural flavours,” said Lisa Hasen, vice-president of OpenTable, Asia Pacific.

John Fink, creative director with the Fink Group, whose restaurants include Bennelong and Otto, and the three hatters Quay and The Bridge Room, said he was seeing an increase in children of all ages – “from first day of kindy to last day of school” – eating at his establishments with their parents.

“It is more likely that the kids want to eat from the grown-up menu these days,” he said. “Young palates with grown-up tastes.”

Mr Fink said the popularity of MasterChef had “changed everything, hands down. Ever since MasterChef hit the small screens in living rooms across the nation young ns have developed a unique fascination with good food and restaurant dining.”

Attitudes to eating out were also changing, he said.

” has a growing culture of what I like to call ‘socialised sophistication’,” he said. “Years back, mum and dad going to a restaurant was a bit posh, and a bit of a deal. Babysitters and taxis got involved. Nowadays folk will head out for a meal with the kids. Dining in a restaurant is part of family life now.”

The 10 most popular gourmet choices for n children, in order of preference:



Smashed eggs on toast

Coconut water



Crème brûlée

Wagyu beef

Almond milk


Source: Galaxy Research for OpenTable


Trust sector looks to busy year ahead

Sydney commercial property is the most sought after by investors. Photo: SuppliedThe n real estate investment trust sector is the first cab off the rank in the upcoming reporting season with expectations the office and industrial managers will be popping the champagne corks, while the retailers will be on the chardonnay.
SuZhou Night Recruitment

The residential sector is resilient but with a slower rate of growth and affordability will remain the topic of discussion.

More takeover activity is predicted, with Mirvac and Investa Office Fund tipped to be the two big targets.

Giving the office landlords a boost were the latest Property Council of Office Market Reports, which showed that while there has been a small rise in vacancy levels, any excess space is likely to be snapped up this year.

Leasing agents agree, saying that telco, internet-related businesses and the new co-sharing enterprises are taking up any spare offices they can find.

And while there has been a lot of new developments, the continued desire to convert older stock in the apartments will help ease the pressure for C and D-grade properties, which are being left behind for the new buildings.

The same applies to the industrial market, where distribution centres are in high demand from the ever-growing e-commerce sector and expectations that will only get stronger.

Retailer are under pressure from overseas entrants, which puts pressure on landlords for rental increases, but investors are still willing to pay high prices for the malls.

CLSA head of real estate Sholto Maconochie says mergers and acquisitions will likely involve Investa Office, where he envisages three scenarios.

“One, it is taken private by Cromwell Property, which already own 9.8 per cent; Cromwell sells its stake to the Investa Commercial Property Fund, which already owns 19 per cent, and it will continue to manage IOF, or Cromwell sells its stake to CIC which then privatises IOF with Mirvac as manager,” he said.

Another is that GPT Group acquires Mirvac and spins off the residential division and Charter Hall Retail REIT merges with Shopping Centres Australasia, but led by Charter Hall.

Winston Sammut​, managing director of Folkestone Maxim Asset Management, has also earmarked IOF and Mirvac as two potential targets.

Mr Sammut’s Folkestone Maxim A-REIT Securities Fund has been reported as the No.1 performing fund over one, two and three years in the Mercer Investment Performance Survey of n Real Estate Securities (REIT) (Active Funds) at December 31, 2016.

He said the fund was focused on the social infrastructure sector such as childcare and medical, and its underweight position in the retail sector was driven by the view that retail is facing enormous headwinds from internet retailing, a competitive retail marketplace with a growing number of international retailers and ongoing margin compression.

Overall, CLSA, says for 2017, despite expectations of bond yields rising, the company has forecast capitalisation rates to compress and valuations to peak.

“We expect regional retail to outperform; large format retail to re-rate; residential to stay resilient but earnings to peak; and strong office fundamentals to finally show up in earnings, but more weighted to the second half of 2017-18 year,” Mr Maconochie said.

“We see a shift from yield to more growth-driven outperformance and expect a 9 per cent total shareholder return, with a preference for active A-REITS over passive.”

Mr Maconochie said he expects prime and secondary office to outperform again this year, but limited to Sydney, Melbourne and potentially Brisbane, due to favourable fundamentals, strong effective rental growth of 5 to 13 per cent, declining vacancy and investor demand.

With prime assets scarce and prime office capitalisation rates at lows of 5.8 per cent, investors are chasing secondary office or developing them to be premium grade, which will see them outperform other assets.


Retailers feeling the pressure from expansion of overseas entrants

Retailers are facing pressure from the overseas brands, higher rents and lack of demand for discretionary items. Photo: Rob Homer RZHThe appointment of voluntary administrators to the owner of the Marcs and David Lawrence brands, Webster Holdings on Thursday, reflects the combativeness of the retail sector and how perilous if can be if consumers swing away.
SuZhou Night Recruitment

Fuelling this is the arrival of the overseas brands, which while not quite direct competitors to the Webster labels, are still turning the screws on local retailers.

The shift in work practices, with more people working from home and increasing casualisation, has also led to less need for business attire across all genders.

Higher rents and a large foot print of stores makes life hard for retailers, particularly when cash is now needed and used for others things, such as mobile devices, and a greater variety of leisure activities.

That leaves less money in the household kitty for discretionary spending and apparel has felt the biggest pressure. This also forces the stores into longer and deeper periods of discounting in order to clear the stock.

According to the receivers, insolvency specialist Rodgers Reidy, they will now begin a review of Webster Holdings, leaving 1200 workers in limbo.

Reflecting the march of the overseas players is the Swedish clothing retailer Hennes & Mauritz, H&M, which  reported a rise in fourth quarter net profits, despite pressure on costs by the strong US dollar.

The company reported profits of 5.9 billion kronor ($A884 million), compared to 5.5 billion kronor in the corresponding period the year before.

The group operated 4351 stores, including franchises, at the end of November. That was an additional 427 stores compared to 2015. In , it continues to open more stores across capital cities and regional areas.

But it is not just the individual retailers putting on the pressure, as investors are also snapping up the malls.

According to the CBRE in its latest Retail MarketView data, 2016 had a record $1.8 billion in CBD retail transactions as foreign investors continue their assault on the n retail investment market.

The CBRE fourth quarter 2016 figures reveal that nationally, retail yields compressed on average 50 basis points last year, with the largest compressions experienced by neighbourhood shopping centres, being 60bps and large format retail, also 60bps.

CBRE senior research manager, , Danny Lee, said the contribution from foreign investors increased in 2016 to account for 30 per cent of total investments, an increase over the 25 per cent experienced in 2015 and well above the long-term trend of 10 per cent.

“Foreign investors have a lower required return expectation than domestic investors and have purchased some of the largest retail assets in 2016, particularly in Melbourne and Sydney,” Mr Lee said.

Mark Wizel, national director, n retail investment properties at CBRE, said investors were viewing retail as the most attractive asset class due to it having the best risk adjusted return.

“The retail sector is now contributing 31 per cent to total commercial property transactions, compared with 25 per cent two years ago,” Mr Wizel said.

“Rent growth coupled with yield compression saw strong growth in capital values, particularly in Sydney CBD, which has encouraged some owners to take advantage of conditions and dispose of assets. Foreign buyers have been actively seeking CBD assets and are willing to pay a higher price to acquire them.”

Mr Wizel said shopping centre yields continued to firm over the year, with regional, sub regional and neighbourhood yields compressing by 20 bps, 40 bps and 60 bps respectively.

“Neighbourhood shopping centres in all states including Tasmania continue to remain high on the shopping list of a range of private, corporate and institutional investors. However, it has been the emergence of the Chinese buyer for such assets that is starting to add significant pricing competition into the sector with yields continually achieved around the country at less than 5.25 per cent,” Mr Wizel said.

“Large format retail is also attracting foreign investors, particularly Chinese buyers who are seeking exposure to retail and with the lack of shopping centres being made available to the market are aggressively chasing large format retail assets.”


Litbits February 4 2017

Historian Geoffrey Blainey. Photo: Pat ScalaFebruary 5: Diana Thompson will discuss her romance novel Unbridled Passion at Muse Canberra at 3pm. Tickets $10 includes a drink. musecanberra苏州夜总会招聘.au.
SuZhou Night Recruitment

February 7: Dr Norman Swan (ABC Health Report) Dr Richard Dennis, Prof Alastair Woodward and others will discuss the late Tony McMichael’s new book Climate Change and the Health of Nations at The n Centre on China in the World, ANU at 5pm. Admission is free. goo.gl/uk9IBz.

February 7: In the free Fellowship Presentation Pinafores, Prodigies & Precocities, Dr Gillian Arrighi explores the era of the child performer during the days of the British Empire, 1880–1914. Conference Room, Level 4, 5.30pm, National Library of . Bookings: nla.gov.au.

February 8: Historian Geoffrey Blainey’s The Story of ‘s People: The Rise and Rise of a New traces the country’s history from the gold rush to the present day. Foyer Theatre, ground floor, National Library of , 6pm. $15 includes book signing and refreshments. Bookings: nla.gov.au.

February 8: The next Poetry at the House reading in the Drawing Room of University House features readings from Chloe Wilson from Melbourne and and Keith Harrison and P.S. Cottier (from Canberra). Admission: $10 waged, $5 unwaged. Meals available in the Fellows Bar and Cafe from 6pm. Readings at 7.30pm.Bookings to Geoff Page: [email protected]苏州夜场招聘.au.

February 9: Join the Friends of the National Library for Revolution Francaise!, a white-gloves viewing of some of the library’s collection of original French Revolution pamphlets and other related items. Conference Room, Friends Lounge, Level 4, National Library of , 6pm. $15 Friends, $20 others. Light refreshments will be served after the collection viewing. Bookings essential. nla.gov.au.

February 12: Join author Tania McCartney for a free interactive reading of her children’s book This is Banjo Paterson, about one of ‘s best-known poets at the National Library of Bookshop at 11am. Children must be accompanied by an adult. Bookings: nla.gov.au.

February 12: National Gallery of Director Gerard Vaughan comes to Muse Canberra to talk about the saucy life of the French court so you can appreciate the exhibition Versailles: Treasures from the Palace.Tickets $10 includes a drink. musecanberra苏州夜总会招聘.au.

February 15: Fairfax columnist Clementine Ford’s new book, Fight Like a Girl, is a manifesto for feminists new, old and soon-to-be, and exposes just how unequal the world continues to be for women. Foyer Theatre, ground floor, National Library of , 6pm. $15 includes book signing and refreshments. Bookings: nla.gov.au.

February 17: The n Comic Arts Festival is on at the Conference Room, Level 4, National Library of from 1 to 5pm. Discover the Library’s own comic collection, and explore comics as literature, collectables and objects for academic study. nla.gov.au.

February 20: Hosted by the ANU and the National Library of , award-winning writer Kate Grenville discusses her latest book The Case Against Fragrance with former Canberra Times literary editor Gia Metherell at the National Library of Theatre, Lower Ground `1, at 6pm. $15 includes book signing and refreshments. Bookings: nla.gov.au.

February 21:State of Hope – Griffith Review, exploring the economic, social, environmental and cultural challenges facing South with Dennis Atkins, Angela Woollacott, Peter Stanley and Chris Wallace, will be on at .the Theatre, Lower Ground 1, National Library of at 6pm. Free admission. Bookings: nla.gov.au.

February 22: In NGA Book Club at 10.30am, join Claudia Hyles for a discussion exploring literary themes around the visual arts.This season’s book is Peacock and vine: Fortuny and Morris in life and at work by AS Byatt. Meet at the National Gallery of information desk. $18, $15 NGA members. Bookings: nga.gov.au.

February 22: Captain James Cook: Claiming the Great Southern Land by John Molony will be launched by the author Professor Iain McCalman at the National Library of Bookshop at 6pm. Free admission, Bookings: nla.gov.au.

February 23: Tony Kevin will be signing copies of his book Return to Moscow at Paperchain Bookstore, Manuka on February 23 at 6pm. The book will be launched by former chief minister Jon Stanhope. RSVP [email protected]苏州夜总会招聘.au.

February 26: Canadian author Madeleine Thien will discuss her whose recent book, Do Not Say We Have Nothing, which was shortlisted for the 2016 Man Booker Prize for Literature. The novel is about the far-reaching effects of China’s revolutionary history, told through the stories of two interlinked musical families, from the 1940s to the present day. National Library of Theatre, Lower Ground 1, 6pm. $18 includes book signing and refreshments. Bookings: nla.gov.au.

* Contributions to Litbits are welcome. Please email [email protected]苏州夜总会招聘.au by COB on the Monday prior to publication. Publication is not guaranteed.


Diplomatic stoush between Trump and Turnbull highlights refugee plight to the world

US President Donald Trump has called a deal between and the Obama administration “dumb”. Refugee Amin Abofetileh in the jungle on Los Negros island, next to Manus Island, Papua New Guinea. Photo: Ashley Gilbertson
SuZhou Night Recruitment

Immigration Minister Peter Dutton (foreground) and Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull (background). Photo: Michele Mossop

As the dust settles from the now-infamous phone call between Donald Trump and Malcolm Turnbull, the world’s media is beginning to focus on the issue that caused their spat.

Donald Trump took to Twitter on Thursday to call a refugee deal with a “dumb deal” and declare he would “study it”.

“Do you believe it?” he wrote. “The Obama Administration agreed to take thousands of illegal immigrants from .”

Since then, media organisations in the United States, the UK and New Zealand have put the deal – and the 1200 people it concerns – under the microscope.

The Los Angeles Times pointed out that conditions on Manus Island and Nauru have been repeatedly criticised by Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch.

“The refugees are the collateral damage in ‘s widely criticized ‘Stop the Boats’ policy,” the LA Times wrote. “Many have reported that the biggest problem is the sense of paralysis at being trapped in limbo indefinitely.”

Another media site, Quartz, said the refugees were “languishing for years in offshore detention facilities”. An interviewee described the detainees as being “held hostage”.

In its explainer of the issue, news and media site Vox said conditions in the camps were “appalling”.

“Detainees have resorted to self-immolation to draw attention to their plight,” Vox said. ” continue[s] to look for any solution that wouldn’t require it to actually accept the refugees. That’s where the US comes in.”

The Atlantic and the New York Times also highlighted the plight of the refugees, the former in a story that asked: “Is the Refugee Deal With ‘Dumb’?”

“Although accepted 13,756 refugees in 2014-15, the period for which the most recent data are available, the country’s policy of offshore-detention centers for asylum-seekers who arrive by boat has been widely criticized,” The Atlantic said.

The Timespublished a video diary showing the daily life of a refugee on the “hell-hole” Manus Island.

Meanwhile, in the UK, the Daily Mirror described the conditions the refugees were living in as “pitiful”.

“The refugees are living under armed guard in squalid conditions – and getting cameras in to expose their plight has been near impossible,” the Mirror wrote.

In 2015, Immigration Minister Peter Dutton brushed off the United Nations Human Rights Council’s criticism of .

“We were criticised by, I noted, Bangladesh, by Iran, by North Korea. North Korea was my favourite,” Mr Dutton told the ABC’s 7.30.

“Frankly, I think it belittles the UN process when you’ve got countries like North Korea trying to lecture our country in relation to human rights.”

With more people around the world becoming aware of the Manus and Nauru deal, it’s possible this criticism could soon come from the US and the UK.


‘No one of that era is completely exonerated’ over financial scandal, former RSL councillor Rod Bain says

Dr Rod Bain says some councillors and staff had failed to keep the rest of the RSL coucil informed about the financial issues. Photo: Phil HearneAn RSL NSW state councillor who resigned recently on principle over the financial scandal engulfing the league has made a frank admission that “no one of that era is completely exonerated” as the leadership faces a looming grassroots backlash.
SuZhou Night Recruitment

Fairfax Media can also reveal that one state councillor is the subject of an investigation over whether Bondi Junction sub-branch, of which he is secretary, has illegally denied membership to an RAAF veteran.

Bill Harrigan, a former n Federal Police officer, could face a disciplinary tribunal if an RSL investigator finds evidence he has used his power to exclude dissenters as the veteran claims. Mr Harrigan denies the allegations.

The state councillor who has resigned, Rod Bain, told Fairfax Media that information was withheld from some councillors about the financial issues that are now the subject of investigations by police, the charities watchdog and internal auditors appointed by the league’s national council.

These include credit card spending of $475,000 by former state president Don Rowe and hundreds of thousands of dollars paid in consulting fees by the RSL’s aged care arm to several state councillors including stood-aside national president Rod White.

Dr Bain, who himself is implicated in none of the alleged wrongdoing, said that some councillors and staff had failed to keep the rest of the council informed about the financial issues.

But he added: “We as directors at that time also might well be accused of failing in our performance of the necessary due diligence required and did not double check exactly what we were being told.

“No one of that era is completely exonerated if we consider the duties and responsibilities of a director to a board.”

The state council faces rising rank-and-file anger, with a push within the Far Western Metropolitan District for a vote of no confidence in the council followed by its removal and replacement by an administrator, according to internal emails seen by Fairfax Media.

On Friday, the state council faced a closed hearing in Canberra to answer charges by the national council of bringing the league into disrepute and for failing to properly deal with Mr Rowe’s credit card spending.

The national council has demanded the NSW leadership show cause why it shouldn’t be dissolved.

On the Bondi Junction stoush, NSW chief executive Glenn Kolomeitz – an East Timor and Afghanistan Army veteran – met with Mr Kawicki two weeks ago and heard Mr Kawicki’s complaint that Mr Harrigan had used his positions to quash dissent at the sub-branch and RSL club.

Mr Kolomeitz later wrote to Mr Kawicki saying “the issues you raised with me are very concerning such that it is my intention to refer the matter to the RSL NSW state branch investigator for investigation”.

Another veteran who clashed with Mr Harrigan, Frank Bugner, said he had been physically escorted from Bondi Junction club after a sub-branch meeting and as a result had joined Maroubra sub-branch instead.

Mr Harrigan said Mr Kawicki had failed to renew his sub-branch membership 2011 and had been denied renewal three years later because of his behaviour.

“I’m held in very, very high esteem by the membership … and I’ve always worked hard for the RSL,” Mr Harrigan said.

Mr Kawicki said as a life member he did not have to pay renewal fees. He said he tried to renew repeatedly and had never been informed in writing as per the league constitution that his membership was being revoked.

Follow us on Facebook


Liberal Party-linked fundraising body Cormack Foundation bankrolling two Senate crossbench parties

Former Family First senator Bob Day and with Liberal Democrats senator David Leyonhjelm at Parliament House in Canberra.A wealthy fundraising body linked to the Liberal Party has quietly begun bankrolling the organisations behind two of the Coalition’s biggest crossbench supporters in the finely balanced Senate.
SuZhou Night Recruitment

The Cormack Foundation has donated more than $40 million to the Liberal Party over the last 18 years – including more than $3 million in 2015-16 – making it one of the party’s biggest benefactors.

The foundation is an investment company and “associated entity” of the Liberals that donates dividends from its share portfolio. It has stakes in a number of blue-chip companies – including the big four banks, Rio Tinto, BHP Billiton, Telstra and Wesfarmers – raising about $3.9 million last year.

But for the first time in its 30-year history, the foundation last year donated to parties other than the Liberals – giving $25,000 each to the conservative Family First and the libertarian Liberal Democrats, according to the n Election Commission annual returns released this week.

The foundation has eight listed shareholders, who are also the company’s directors. They include Rupert Murdoch’s brother-in-law John Calvert-Jones, former Reserve Bank board member and Business Council of president Hugh Morgan and former ANZ chairman Charles Goode.

The donations came in a year that the Abbott and then Turnbull governments were highly reliant in the Senate on the votes of Family First’s Bob Day and the Liberal Democrats’ David Leyonhjelm.

The men were generally supportive of the government’s agenda in both the former Parliament and the current one. An analysis of their first year in the chamber found Mr Day voted with the government 90 per cent of the time and Senator Leyonhjelm more than 70 per cent of the time.

It’s believed to be the first occasion an “associated entity” has linked itself to more than one political party at a time.

The $25,000 donation represented nearly 30 per cent of Family First’s total donations for 2015-16. For the Liberal Democrats it represented slightly less than 5 per cent.

Cormack Foundation secretary Peter Matthey insisted the company is not a Liberal Party vehicle and supports a number of organisations.

“Cormack Foundation donates to libertarian causes – that’s the reason for its existence,” he told Fairfax Media.

But AEC documents show that, up until last financial year, the foundation never listed any parties other than the Liberals under the disclosure subhead titled “With which party, or parties, is the entity associated?”

Family First does not describe itself as libertarian and indeed Mr Day – who resigned from the Senate last year after his national building empire collapsed – actively resisted the label. Family First could not be contacted for comment.

“I’m not going to go into the detail of the discussions around how that was worked out,” Mr Matthey said.

Mr Matthey is a retired chartered accountant who was a partner at auditor KPMG. He says the foundation is totally transparent.

Senator Leyonhjelm said of the foundation’s support: “We approached them. They like my small government message, is what they told me.”

He said his party did not co-ordinate with Family First in its approach to the foundation.

“A couple of donors decided to include Family First after agreeing to give us something. Must have been something about minor parties,” he said.

But Greens democracy spokesperson Lee Rhiannon said it was extraordinary the Liberals’ biggest donor was also funding rival political parties.

“Considering an associated entity is defined as a body that undertakes fundraising for a particular party, the Cormack Foundation’s action suggests a new level of collaboration between these three parties,” she said.

“The Cormack Foundation returns shows a financial link between the Liberals, Liberal Democrats and Family First that could imply a consolidation of political co-operation between these parties.

“The financial links might also play out politically with increased collaboration on preference deals and voting in support of each other in the Senate.”


Previous Posts